Skip to main content

Evidence Hierarchy: Resource of the week #45

What is it?
The Evidence Hierarchy is a pyramid that aims to represent the relative quality of evidence, the hierarchy, that can be determined from various study types. It is suggested that not all evidence is the same, with different study types being subject to strengths, weaknesses, flaws and biases.
The study types listed at the top of the pyramid are considered to provide better quality evidence than those at the bottom.

There are a variety of different definitions of what is included in the pyramid and there is even some contention as to how useful it is.


Key Features
One of the key things to remember is that the pyramid is only giving you a representation of the quality of the study design, not whether the article you are looking at is “good” or “poor”. You will still need to critically appraise the research paper – for example you may be looking at a randomised controlled trial, but if it has not been carried out well, the article may not be helpful for you.

eTutorial
You can try our etutorial Evidence Hierarchy to learn more about the evidence hierarchy. We also include the description of some common study types.

More help?
You find more about the evidence hierarchy and evidence-based medicine in our book collection

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Hot topic! Hantavirus

 With the cruise ship in port and the travellers heading home the Hantavirus outbreak has been in the news recently. Learn more about this disease from library resources. Check these resources for an overview, key points, diagnosis, treatment options, follow-up and more. [You will need your NHS OpenAthens username to access these resources] BMJ Best Practice – Hantavirus cardiopulmonary syndrome Oxford Medicine Online – Hantavirus cardiopulmonary syndrome in Clinical Infectious Disease (3 rd ed) Selected articles from our journal collection Critical care management of hantavirus cardiopulmonary syndrome. A narrative review , Journal of Critical Care , Ulloa-Morrison, Rodrigo; Pavez, Nicolas; Parra, Esteban; Lopez, Rene; Mondaca, Roberto; Fernandez, Paula; Kraunik, David; Sanhueza, Claudia; Bravo, Sebastian; Cornu, Matias Germán; Kattan, Eduardo, Vol. 84, p. 154867, 2024. Hantavirus in humans: a review of clinical aspects and management , The Lancet Infectious Dis...

Article integrity checks for NHS staff

Want to have extra quality and integrity checks for the articles you find? Use library NHS resources and get warnings if the article you're reading fails integrity checks. NHS resources use LibKey to easily point you to subscribed resources. Now LibKey also does a number of integrity checks to help you feel confident with the articles you find. You’ll get warnings about: Retracted articles Retracted article citation (where an article includes references to articles which have been retracted) Expression of concern for the article (where publishers have concerns about some aspect of a published article) Problematic publishers information Warnings are presented at point of access whether from article links in databases or on the web via LibKey Nomad. Make sure you use library resources so that you are using LibKey links and integrity checks. For more help please contact the eresources librarian c.kent@keele.ac.uk

Introducing a New Reading Experience in Clinical Key

  Clinical Key is a clinical search engine provided for our UHNM users only. Reading Assistant – a new feature from Clinical Key Clinical Key is adding a Reading Assistant, an integrated generative AI feature designed to help you quickly comprehend and navigate complex clinical content. This enhancement uses structured summarisation and inline clarification to present key insights from book chapters and journal articles, all while keeping the original expert-authored content fully visible and authoritative. What the Reading Assistant Provides Concise, structured summaries of the content currently on the page Clarification of complex concepts without changing the underlying evidence Faster navigation through long chapters and dense journal articles Reduced cognitive load when approaching complex or lengthy material How It Works — Designed for Clinical Reliability The Reading Assistant has been built with a strong emphasis on safety, privacy, and the integrity of evidence...