Skip to main content

Critical Appraisal – are there any tools that can help you? (#24)

When you are looking at research articles you need to appraise them critically for validity, results and relevance. This means looking at the paper in a systematic way to determine whether it is going to help you to answer your question.

There are a wide range of tools that can help you to develop your skills in doing this. Our etutorial Critical Appraisal Tools will introduce you to some tools that can help. The tools do not necessarily give you a definitive “yes” or “no” but they help you to ask the right questions to assess the paper.

Tools icon - use critical appraisal tools to help you to assess research papers
Tools icon - use critical appraisal tools to help you to assess research papers

In a similar way that we use the CRAAP tool (see previous blog post) if an item fails your appraisal it does not necessarily mean that it is a rubbish paper, just that it will not help you to answer your question.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Login to Library Search – step-by-step instructions for NHS staff

  Library Search is a discovery tool, allowing you to find items within the library collections. You can search Library Search without logging in to view books and ebooks available in our collections. By logging in to your library account on Library Search you can access a range of additional functionality, such as: Viewing details of your library account Submitting a request to hold a book for you Adding items to your e-bookshelf Saving searches Note that for NHS users logging in to Library Search does not give you access to full-text items. As an NHS member of staff you access online resources using your NHS OpenAthens username. Anatomy of a Library Card First let’s take a quick look at the most important components of your library card. Your library card and library card number give you access to print resources as well as library services. They confirm that you are a member of the library. Your name : this will be printed on your card, so you’ll know it’s yours!...

New BMJ titles added to the NHS Core Content collection

 A number of BMJ titles have been added to the NHS Core Content collection this year. This collection is available to all NHS staff. You can access the full-text articles via your NHS OpenAthens username. The new titles are: BMJ Leader - an international, peer-reviewed, online-only journal focusing on leadership in health and care BMJ Innovations - a peer reviewed journal focused on novel technologies, emerging digital health and pioneering medical devices BMJ Military Health - home of research, reviews and commentary on the key issues in military health European journal of hospital pharmacy - official journal of the European Association of Hospital Pharmacists (EAHP), committed to advancing the science, practice and profession of hospital pharmacy Access our journals collections from the Journals page on our website. For help accessing any information you need please contact the Health Library .

BMJ Best Practice and state-of-the-art care for patients with Heart Failure

  Join this informative online webinar designed to strengthen your approach to heart failure management using BMJ Best Practice. Date:  Wednesday 19 November 2025 Time:  2pm to 3pm Platform:  Microsoft Teams About the Webinar:  In this session, our expert speakers will guide you through leveraging BMJ Best Practice to deliver outstanding, evidence-based care for patients with heart failure and gain practical insights to improve management and patient outcomes. Speakers: Dr Kieran Walsh, Clinical Director, BMJ Dr Shrilla Benerjee, Consultant Interventional Cardiologist and BMJ Best Practice Author Learning Outcomes: Challenges in implementing evidence-based medicine in the management of heart failure Managing comorbidities in patients with heart failure The role of patient information Common pitfalls in management and how to overcome them Who Should Attend? This webinar is ideal for healthcare professionals, including doctors, nurses, pharmacists, and medical stu...